Before UberEats, DoorDash and GrubHub owned the doorstep, Milk Bar had a decision to make. People lined up for Birthday Cake and Compost Cookies®. The question was how to reach them when they wanted dessert at home. Milk Bar could partner with the marketplaces and become one tile in a grid, or build its own app and own the whole experience.
My team and I were asked to design a custom ordering experience and help figure out which path made more financial sense. We weighed brand experience, customer data, commissions, reach, build cost and the potential for loyalty. At the time, the answer was to build. A premium brand earns its price in the details, from the voice to the pink box on the doorstep, and we didn’t want those details flattened into someone else’s template.
We designed every step to feel like Milk Bar. The first thing you see is a cake, not a login. The categories are the treats themselves. Sizes say how many people they serve. One sheet turns a cake into a birthday, with candles, a gift message, truffles and a delivery time.
We designed an end-to-end iOS app:
Then the market changed. The marketplaces became the place people start when they’re hungry, and being where the customers were mattered more than owning the screen. Milk Bar retired the app and partnered with the big players. The thinking we did on gifting, reorders and the unboxing still shapes how a premium brand should show up wherever its customers order.